Dear All,

How would Steve's suggestd exercise work if it were applied, not to  

CJ, but to economic analysis of law and, more particularly, the  

judgments of Richard Posner?  I presume RP will have taken the USA  

equivalent of  the oath that Jason mentions.  Furthermore, the econ  

analysis approach, so far as I understand it (which isn't very far),  

would come up against Jason's immanence retort.

I ask not to see Jason and Steve come to yet further cyberspace blows  

- even though I'm enjoying their exchange - just out idle curiosity.

John M